We ran into a situation where a wide MDX query requesting many regular and semi-additive measures side by side can degrade the Analysis Services server performance. As I explained in this connect bug report, the customer had a Reporting Services report that includes many measures (close to a hundred). Users insisted on having this report to be able to export all results in Excel and pivot on them. Of course, one of the advantages of having a cube is to make this exact requirement unnecessary but old habits die hard. We've noticed that when the report includes 75 measures from a single measure group, the query executes within 20 seconds. However, when adding more measures from the same measure group, the query performance degrades to minutes. The measures are either regular (persisted) measures or simple calculated member wrappers and don't use any intensive formulas or scope assignments. The important point is that the query requests both additive and semi-additive measures (in our case the semi-additive measures use the LastChild function).
Microsoft determined that the performance degradation occurs when the number of overlapping calculations for a part of the cube space exceeds a threshold causing the server to switch from block mode to cell by cell evaluation for the affected query space. Microsoft was quick to provide us with a private fix that addresses the issue by distinguishing when the overlapping calculations are due to semi-additive measures vs. scope assignments in the cube script or query scope calculations (the reason the original limit was present). It will also allow the administrator to configure the threshold by adjusting the MaxCoverItemOverlapCount setting in msmdsrv.ini file although raising this number too high could result in negative performance on some cases where the cell by cell evaluation of highly complex calculations is faster than the block evaluation method. The official fix will be included in CU4 for SQL Server 2012 expected in mid-October 2012. I'm not sure about if the fix will make it to the older versions of SQL Server.
Sun, Sep 16 2012 5:13 PM